Cellular Memory, Fact or Farce? - Instablogs
Cellular Memory, Fact or Farce?
Alice Vosloo , Johannesburg: May 30 2008
Made Popular May 30 2008

Cellular Memory, Fact or Farce?

Do cells have feelings and emotions? As far as I’m concerned they don’t, however I do firmly believe that your state of mind influence the ‘health’ of your cells. I also believe the old saying ‘healthy body healthy mind’. What really interests me though is a theory/phenomenon called Cellular Memory. It involves the idea that “things as memories, habits, interests, and tastes may somehow be stored in all the cells of human bodies, i.e. not only in the brain”. This would mean that with organ transplants information and energy stored in the organ is passed on to the recipient. The theory would apply to any organ that has cells that are interconnected, but it seems like heart-transplant recipients are most affected.

What are the consequences of this, should it be true? According to those who believe in it, organ recipients experienced changes in personality traits, tastes for food, music, activities and even sexual preference after their transplants. Many such stories have been recorded. One of the most dramatic examples, according to an article by Leslie A. Takeuchi, is ‘… an eight-year-old girl who received the heart of a ten-year-old girl who had been murdered. After the transplant, the recipient had horrifying nightmares of a man murdering her donor. The dreams were so traumatic that psychiatric help was sought. The girl’s images were so specific that the psychiatrist and the mother notified the police. According to the psychiatrist, “. . .using the description from the little girl, they found the murderer. He was easily convicted with the evidence the patient provided. The time, weapon, place, clothes he wore, what the little girl he killed had said to him . . . everything the little heart transplant recipient had reported was completely accurate.”’

While some stories are very dramatic, there are also more ‘ordinary’ examples of people whose taste in food have changed etc. According to Takeuchi’s article, Dr Mehmet Oz, famous for appearing on the Oprah Show, believes that there must be something to it. “Mehmet Oz, MD, heart surgeon at Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center, has invited an energy healer, Julie Motz, into the operating room during transplant surgery. Initially, Motz practiced energy healing to help reduce anxiety prior to surgery and depression following surgery. Then the team noticed that there seemed to be less incidence of rejection in these patients. They were curious to see what would happen if she were present during the operation. Motz registers, through sensations in her own body, the emotional state of the patient during the surgical procedure. Through her touch or words, Motz attempts to alleviate any worries, fears or anger the patient may be experiencing. She works with the recipient’s ability to accept the new organ and also works with the donated tissue so it will accept a new body. The results have been favorable, and the team reports reduced rejection and increased survival rates”

However not everyone feels this way about Cellular Memory. According to The Skeptic’s Dictionary “Maybe our ancestors were right. Eating the heart of one’s enemy might give you his courage. Eating brains might make you smarter. Maybe the promoters of TCM are right: eating seal penises can restore erectile function. But what if you eat too much chicken? Might you grow a beak, start clucking uncontrollably, and develop a craving for seeds? Are those squealing and mooing sounds you hear in the night your diabetic neighbors who are using porcine and bovine insulin? Pity the poor child who received a baboon’s heart.” Admittedly, eating something is not the same as having it transplanted in your body! More seriously though, they do feel that ‘an organ transplant is a life-altering experience, literally. It might well be compared to the near-death experience since transplants are done only if death is imminent. It should not be surprising to find that many transplant recipients change significantly. Some of these changes might easily be interpreted as being consistent with the donor’s likes and dislikes or behaviors. Recipients would want to know about their donor and might consciously or unconsciously be influenced by stories about the person who now “lives inside them.”’.
I also feel that the effect of post-transplant medications should be taken into account. For example Prednisone may cause increased appetite, depression and changes in personality. The human mind is also very suggestible. If I for example had to be told that my donor loved a certain kind of food or music, I could definitely start imagining liking those things myself. And because I’ve seen no difference in myself, I’m not convinced…

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Sanwali
Shimla, India
I still don’t believe in the example that you gave of an 8yr old girl’s heart transplant. But if it is true: I’m stunned.
1 Stars
Scott
Albuquerque, United States
Alice i just don't agree with the memory being stored in other parts of the body...this is just stupid whining over a regulated program. Organ transplants are to save life and that's it.

people make these kinda stories up...or its like when you come outta operation theater and its told to you that someone's lungs saved your life...you would obviously like to know who that departed soul was and you start making stories or somehow start to get connected to that guy who now lives right inside you.

then how about saying hey doc i don't like orange juice anymore...has it to do something with the guy who donated me his lungs. Did he liked the orange juice? Ok incase he didn't...you have more than a chance to say that i am a changed guy now...i am not who i used to be...you know that's what i think about this story...i really got into it...that's nice, even i started making stories;)
1 Stars
Alice Vosloo livinglifebreathless..
Johannesburg, South Africa
Yeah Scott and Shimla, I totally agree. If the girl with the heart’s story is true, I don’t think anyone can explain it. I’m sure a lot of these stories are made up, and as I said, the mind is very suggestable...
1 Stars
Leena
Kolkata, India
The example of the 8 year old reminds of the hollywood movie ’The eye’ in which a girl who had eye transplantation had horrible experiences.

Cellular memory is quite a debatable issue today and though cases of personality changes are being reported in paitents undetgoing organ transplantation lets hope that it does not turn out to be true....otherwise people will start acting really wierd.
1 Stars
Paul Williams
Johannesburg, South Africa
Transplantation is such an emotive issue no wonder people try and mystify it even more. I remain sceptical as usual about such paranormal phenomena. During and after transplantation-especially when cardio-pulmonary bypass has been used-a certain effect on brain function must be expected. This along with the neuro side effects of drugs is responsible. Most patients hopefully feel healthier after transplantation and this is incorrectly noted as personality change
Add your Comment