When does patriotism become offensive?
15 Star
Share This Post
Alice Vosloo , Johannesburg: Apr 22 2008
Made Popular Apr 22 2008

A few recent events, including this article in the Sunday Times two days ago, have really managed to get me, and probably a lot of other South Africans, thinking… ‘When does patriotism become offensive’? 007-thumb_16668

According to Wikipedia patriotism is a supportive attitude toward your country/nation, and implies that the individual should place the interest of their nation over personal or group interests. Patriotism also “covers such attitudes as: pride in its achievements and culture, the desire to preserve its character and the basis of the culture, and identification with other members of the nation. In wartime, the sacrifice may extend to their own life.”

Being an Afrikaans girl, I’m obviously an Afrikaner, although coming from Port Elizabeth which is predominantly English, and having been to schools filled with mostly English, Xhosa and Coloured pupils etc, I’ve never felt close to the Afrikaner identity, and can sometimes be quite ashamed of the ‘beer-and-braaivleis’ brigade. And I definitely wouldn’t die for my country. Not the South Africa we’re living in right now anyway.

Recent events such as Bok van Blerk’s song ‘De La Rey’, and the upcoming play ‘Ons vir Jou’ have created some controversy among South Africans. Is it right to celebrate a war hero (from the Afrikaner perspective) in a war where so many people died? Or is Koos Kombuis right when he says: “If I was De la Rey, Deon, I would sue you for defamation. De la Rey wasn’t a warmonger, but a man of peace. He was a pragmatic and a progressive thinker. He didn’t live in the past like you.”
I tend to agree with Johrné van Huyssteen who says: “When I think of Bloedrivier, I respect the history. The Zulus who died were also fathers and people who wanted a country. The time has come to rather spend R4-million on writing a big nation-building musical that brings balance to the country and uplifts us all.” But then again, we get bombarded by the government’s superficial attempts at ‘nation-building’, which is usually not very successful. And is it wrong to be proud of a man who was (apparently) very brave and selfless? Even though the past is not something I, as an Afrikaner, am proud of, can we just pretend it didn’t happen?

Shouldn’t we maybe celebrate the worthy heroes that there were, regardless of which race/culture they belonged to? As long as it is not at the expense of, or deliberately excluding other cultures in our country. That might work for some real nation-building. Being proud of the deserving people, regardless of their language or race.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Manual Upload
Sorry, no media found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Syed
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
We should draw distinctions between patriotism and nationalism because nationalism is much more dangerous than patriotism. Such concepts go too far when they are used as an excuse to hurt and diminish others. Obsession should have no place in patriotism and superiority clubbed with patriotism might become dangerous for the people of any country.
1 Stars
Hasto
Jakarta, Indonesia
Patriotism goes too far when people start thinking about interests of their own country at the expense or others. If some other country, particularly the neighboring country of first one, starts thinking in similar fashion, it creates a problem in that region. It causes people to view other nations as inferior and it goes offensive.
1 Stars
Arnold
Manila, Philippines
Patriotism has a tendency to become a problem for people when it starts pushing people away from other groups or nations. The more proud they feel of their country, the easier it might be to feel that other countries aren't equal to them.
2 Stars
Allan
Wellington, New Zealand
I had highly patriotic mind when I was in school and university but now I can say that I am not patriotic because I see no sense in being rigid patriotic. I have visited so many countries now and lived in other countries for longer time. I found all the people proud of their heritage and culture. Every country has a unique character that it has brought to the world. they all are proud of their country. I found that nationalism is practically unwanted in today's global world.
1 Stars
Nkosipile
London, United Kingdom
Yes it goes defensive when citizens of any country start hating people of other countries as Irish people hate the English. I become patriotic when the English rugby team loses a match but I also appreciate when other teams play better than English team.
1 Stars
Jesse
Manila, Philippines
Like Allan, I am also not a strong patriot and I believe Australia is a great country because people of diverse culture live in the country. It grants people the quality of life to enjoy. So, I am seriously thinking to go and settle in Australia. because I want to live in a country where the laws are better and fairer.
0 Stars
Alice Vosloo livinglifebreathless..
Johannesburg, South Africa
Yes, I truly agree that it becomes dangerous then patriotism is at the expense of others, and that ANY type of obsession is dangerous. And even though you don’t ’hurt’ someone else. pushing them away is just as bad.
Add your Comment